Former MP demands name of local authority

Children|January 11th 2016

Former MP John Hemming has criticised the family court’s refusal to name a local authority which breached a father’s rights.

The man’s four year-old daughter had been living with her mother after her parents separated, but was taken into foster care amid concerns from the local authority that she was being neglected. However, they did not ask the father if he was able to care for his daughter, nor did they ask him to suggest other possible carers.

In a judgment last year, Her Honour Judge Heather Anderson declared that the local authority’s actions were a breach of the father’s right to a fair trial and to respect for family life. The council accepted their mistakes and admitted they had not done enough to correct their errors.

The judge ruled that disclosing the name of the local authority itself, or any of the individuals involved in this case, “will not serve any useful purpose”. She added that social workers “work under huge pressure, much of it imposed by the requirements of the court”.

This week, John Hemming criticised the judge’s decision, claiming that the public should be told which local authority was responsible for the breaches.

The former Liberal Democrat MP for Birmingham Yardley said that the “taxpayer funds this local authority, voters have elected the councillors responsible for it” and, as a result, the public has “a right to know what is done in their name”.

He added that it was “simply not good enough to keep the name of the council secret” because of the “huge pressure” the social workers were under. “Unless we know where things have gone wrong they cannot be put right”, he insisted.

To read Judge Anderson’s original judgment in full, click here.

Photo by Matt McGee via Flickr

Share This Post...


  1. Andrew says:

    When John Hemming is right somebody else has to very, very wrong but I suppose he can’t be wrong all the time, his best efforts notwithstanding, and this time he is right and the judge is wrong!

  2. Amber Hartman says:

    Hemming is right on this one but its a shame he isn’t transparent about the allegations made against him where investigations are ongoing. Double standards?

    In order to improve the system we can only learn if full facts and details are presented. It is unfair for others who may have the opportunity to put forward suitable kin care so children can stay within the family circle or extended family wherever possible which would save the government money.

    No matter how much pressure people are under, no-one should be playing with innocent people’s lives. That is so wrong.

Leave a Reply


Newsletter Sign Up

For all the latest news from Stowe Family law
please sign up for instant access today.

Privacy Policy