A week in family law: children services at tipping point, an unusual costs order and a celebrity divorce

Family Law|Industry News|September 7th 2018

It has been another quiet week for family law news, as the summer holiday lull continues. Still, we should be thankful for small mercies.

Children services at tipping point

In what must be the least unexpected piece of news, it has been reported that government ministers are facing demands from councils across England for emergency funds to protect thousands of vulnerable children. The news comes after figures revealed that last year alone local authorities had to spend £816m more on children’s social care than they had budgeted for.

As a result, senior local government figures are warning that children’s services are reaching a tipping point, as the numbers needing help continue to grow and budgets continue to shrink.

Roy Perry, the vice-chair of the Local Government Association’s children and young people board, said:

“These figures clearly show the huge and increasing financial pressures children’s services are under, with many councils being pushed to the brink by unprecedented demand. It is not just increased pressure for care for the elderly causing the problem for local authority budgets. Councils have done what they can to protect spending on children’s services and have spent over £800m more than they had budgeted for children’s social care. Councils do not want to cut the very services which are designed to help children and families before problems begin or escalate to the point where a child might need to come into care. We are absolutely clear that, unless new funding is found, these vital services, which keep children safe from harm and the worst abuses of society, will reach a tipping point.”

So, will the Government reach into its pocket to provide proper funding for the ever-increasing numbers of vulnerable children that councils are having to deal with, or will we have to wait until there is another tragedy like the Baby P case, as some fear may happen?

An unusual costs order

The Court of Protection has taken the unusual step of making a costs order against both a Local Authority and a Clinical Commissioning Group after they caused a Colombian woman to be trapped in this country for over three years before she was repatriated. In May 2014 the woman collapsed whilst waiting at a bus stop in London. She was taken to a hospital and found to have suffered a cardiac arrest, which caused her to sustain a brain injury. As a result, she lacked the capacity to make decisions for herself, although she made it clear that she wished to return to Colombia, where she could be cared for by her extended family. She may have been ready to be discharged from hospital in 2014, but due to what the judge described as ‘disorganised, muddled and unfocused decision making, and what has at times verged on an arrogance’, she had to wait for more than three years before she returned home in January this year. The judge concluded ‘without hesitation’ that the circumstances of the case were so poor and so extreme that he should make the costs order.

A celebrity divorce

And finally, I don’t usually refer to celebrity divorce cases here, but I thought this one deserves a mention. The actress Geena Davis, who long ago starred in one of my favourite movies Thelma & Louise, has reportedly responded to her husband’s divorce petition by alleging that they were never legally married. She maintains that they had agreed not to complete the legal formalities of their ‘marriage’ seventeen years ago, as they preferred simply to cohabit. Accordingly, says Ms Davis, the divorce petition should be dismissed. It seems the particularly formality that Ms Davis claims were not followed was that the couple’s marriage licence was not returned to the court clerk after their private wedding ceremony, as it should have been. I’m not sure of the details, but I don’t think that such an issue could arise in this country, as a marriage here must, of course, be conducted by a person, or in the presence of a person, authorised to register marriages, and they would obviously ensure that the marriage was properly registered. Still, a fascinating scenario, and it will be interesting to find out the outcome.

Have a good weekend.

Author: John Bolch

John Bolch often wonders how he ever became a family lawyer. He no longer practises, but has instead earned a reputation as one of the UK's best-known family law bloggers.

Comments(6)

  1. Helen Dudden says:

    John, Contact Centre’s have been useful in the past, for unstable situations.
    I think the funding was removed in Bath, I went to a council meeting, and argued for support in certain sectors of the Community for “at risk” children. Could we add, how useful breakfast clubs are. I know a fast food outlet has a waiting list. I was told a 25 pence donation buys a breakfast. A small donation if you have spare change.

  2. JamesB says:

    Geena Davis, who long ago starred in one of my favourite movies Thelma & Louise,

    Lol. Not sure if it was the semi naked Brad Pitt, or the female empowerment of the lead characters as they go over the cliff or the ineptitude of the lead male detective Harvey Keitel. On all of these and ingeneral I disagree with you though.

    Best part of the film? Can’t remember any. When the lead went off the cliff at the end. Good riddance. Usual women good men bad nonsense. Bad film. Decent buddy movie with strong female character? Try the Judge Dredd film with the new Zealand lead character. At least it doesn’t cheapen the relationships between men and women like T And L does but is more honest and less rubbish in that regard.

  3. JamesB says:

    Keith Urban was as Judge Dredd I think. T and L is destructive chick flick preaching men bad women good leave your man nonsense. I shouldn’t be surprised that you like it given your profession, but I am. Perhaps as I think good art should transient self interest. This summer’s world cup for example.

  4. Proton says:

    Helen, why do you prescribe sticking plaster remedies to huge gaping wounds.
    Society should be using all its resources into preventing divorce not accepting it and dreaming up silly malevolent nonsensical solutions to mitigate divorces obvious factual catastrophes.
    Divorce save for the extreme cases is always wrong.

  5. JamesB says:

    P.s. What’s the story with Boris Johnson?

  6. JamesB says:

    A much better chick flick than T and L would be Boys on the side with Drew Barrymore and Whoopi Goldberg and an appearance by a young Matthew Mccawwnahay (however spelt). Good film that with good, not bitter strong female leads. The man hating era needs to be over for our children’s sake.

Leave a Reply

Close

Newsletter Sign Up

For all the latest news from Stowe Family law
please sign up for instant access today.

Privacy Policy